So the Yankee post season run is officially over after the Red Sox beat the Indians 5-4 yesterday. With Cashman's status for next year a question mark, there are many more question marks in what could be the most influential offseason in the team's history. A number of players will be free agents in the winter, freeing up $80 million in the payroll.
Here's what I think should happen:
2009 Roster
Outfield: Matsui, Nady, Abreu, Gardner. I think alternating Gardner with these guys is a good plan since you can give them days off or put them at DH. I think we should trade Melky while we still can. He is no better than Gardner and I never liked Melky's offense.
1st Base: Johnny Damon. With Giambi coming off the books, most people are speculating that the Yankees are going to pick up Teixeira. I don't understand what gives people the idea that Teix will be available. The Angels have almost as much money as the Yankees and benefit greatly from having him in the lineup. Expect them to lock him up with a long term contract. The first baseman position in baseball is one in which you can get away with having a decent/mediocre fielder since fewest balls are hit there and most of the duties of the position is to catch the ball while keeping your foot on the bag. Look at some of the other first basemen around the majors: Ryan Howard, Prince Fielder, Konerko, Frank Thomas, Kevin Millar, etc. These guys are all hitters. Having Damon at first would seem a little weird since he would be the fastest first basemen in the majors. But that is not to say that is a negative by any means. Damon is no outfielder. A Major League outfielder needs a good arm. He is similar to Juan Pierre of the Dodgers. Damon playing first would also free up the DH spot so players could alternate at that position. Damon is an offensive player at this point in his career, so this move would benefit him as well as the team. Besides, the only free agent first baseman who would be worth getting is Teixeira.
2nd Base: Robinson Cano. I have always been stoked on Cano. While he defense can be lacking at times, he has the skill to win a batting title someday. He also makes some really tough plays at 2nd base. There is no reason to get rid of him.
SS: Jeter. We can't get rid of Jeter. He isn't the best defensive shortstop in the game anymore, but he is still up there. And you can't argue with his defense. He is also the captain. Unlike Varitek, he still contributes to his team's success on the field.
3rd Base: A-Rod. I absolutely hate it when people hate on A-Rod. It's clearly a jealousy issue, with him being the highest paid baseball player. Hopefully, this odd year statistic holds true for the '09 season. '03, '05, '07 were amazing years for him. I personally think he needs a better psychologist. That is why he has clutchness issues.
Pitcher: This is where it gets pretty complicated. I'm going to outline a couple possible scenarios.
Scenario 1: Wang, Mussina, Pettitte, Hughes/Joba/Kennedy, Free agent acquisition
Scenario 2: Wang, Mussina, Hughes, Joba, Free Agent Acquisition
The complicated part of all this is the Free Agent question mark. I would personally throw Melky into the trade talks to get a high quality pitcher. Before Sabathia's trade deadline deal that sent him to the Brewers, I thought he would be a Yankee for sure. But Sabathia demonstrated his ability to hit, which gives NL teams a greater advantage if they acquire him. I expect the Dodgers or some other big market NL team to get him. A.J. Burnett is a possibility; however, I'm not sure that his inconsistency would be aided by a move to the AL East rival Yankees.
My top pick for a free agent acquisition this offseason is Kyle Lohse of the St. Louis Cardinals. Lohse is turning 30 on October 4th and is a solid Young pitcher. He played well this year and seems like he would fit the mold of the future of the Yankees. He is a Native American, so the Yanks would be one of the few organizations with 2 Native American players. Usually, I am not too fond of pitcher acquisitions from the NL. Look at Burnett, Willis, Pavano, etc. However, Lohse held his own this year against the Rays and the Red Sox, who are our division rivals. Against Boston, he gave up 1 earned run over 6 innings at Fenway. He also gave up 2 earned runs over 6 innings against the Rays. Lohse has also pitched in the AL before, so he is used t the level of play.
Here are his stats for the 2008 season through today:
15-6 record
3.78 ERA
1.30 WHIP
119 K
49 BB
One of the main reasons why I like him is that it won't be nearly as hard to get him. Sabathia is going to cost a lot of money and the Brewers own him until the winter so we would have to give up some prospects. Lohse is only 30 and is good enough for the job that we need him to do. Plus, Sabathia has been pitching so many complete games that his value has become diminished.
That is my take on the offseason. Let's hope we get Lohse.